Teddys Coffee & Ice Cream: Delightful Paninis & Refreshing Lemonades

Teddys Coffee & Ice Cream, nestled at 1205 Badger Ave in Fort Morgan, Colorado, is a charming coffee shop that masterfully blends rich, hand-crafted beverages with freshly made, satisfying eats. From the moment you walk in, the welcoming atmosphere, highlighted by friendly staff and a community-focused vibe, invites you to relax and indulge in some of the best coffee and snacks the town has to offer.

The menu at Teddys Coffee & Ice Cream showcases an enticing array of grill-pressed paninis and fresh salads, with each dish prepared thoughtfully and to order. The Roast Beef Dip Panini stands out as a signature favorite, boasting tender slices of roast beef paired with your choice of zesty red pepper aioli or creamy garlic aioli. It's a hearty, flavorful sandwich that promises a mouthwatering experience, especially when dipped into its accompanying au jus.

If you lean towards lighter fare, their Ceaser Salad or Cobb Salad feature fresh greens and proteins, perfectly complemented by an inventive selection of dressings like the new Maple Balsamic or the smoky Poblano Ranch. This thoughtful variety allows guests to customize their meal with dressings that elevate each bite into something memorable.

Beyond the savory offerings, Teddys shines with its creative beverage menu. Patrons rave about their matcha latte — a delicate balance of earthiness and subtle sweetness that rivals any in town—and the chai latte, comforting with its warm, spiced notes. Their freshly squeezed or frozen lemonades are a delightful treat, bursting with vibrant flavors such as strawberry, mango, and the unique desert pear. These drinks not only refresh but also perfectly complement the delicious sandwiches and salads.

Ice cream lovers will find pure joy at Teddys, featuring luxuriously creamy options like cookies and cream, which a delighted customer called “the best I’ve ever had.” The ice cream pairs beautifully with espresso in their affogato, an offering that truly showcases the rich, velvety textures and bold flavors they serve. It’s clear that every item here is crafted with care, blending texture and taste to delight the senses.

Customer experiences reinforce Teddys Coffee & Ice Cream’s appeal. Newcomers consistently highlight the welcoming nature of staff members like Adan, whose kindness and good recommendations make each visit feel personal and inviting. Whether it’s their first time or a return trip, visitors appreciate the attentiveness and warmth that makes Teddys not just a coffee shop, but a community hub.

Even amidst a bustling crowd, as during its grand opening, the owners ensure every guest feels valued, greeting customers and sharing their passion for great food and drink. The wait times may be a bit longer when busy, but with free affogato offers and a friendly smile, the experience remains genuinely rewarding.

For anyone traveling through Fort Morgan or looking to enjoy fresh, quality coffee alongside inventive paninis, standout lemonades, and rich, creamy ice cream, Teddys Coffee & Ice Cream is a must-visit destination. It’s a place where vibrant flavors and heartfelt hospitality come together to create memorable moments you’ll want to savor again and again.

Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Drive-through
Takeaway
Dine-in

Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Assistive hearing loop

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Brenda Valdez

26/11/2025

My husband and I went opening week and ordered a chai latte and a matcha latte and the breakfast panini (not pictured), the wait was long but that is to be expected with a new restaurant, not to mention the amount of people in line too. The staff were friendly and the drinks and food were very good. I think they might have the best matcha in town (many are so cloyingly sweet) and the panini was a substantial size, well worth the price in my opinion. It's hard to review a place on price when you can ask for the total and then make the decision to leave before placing the order. Teddy's can cost more than other options in town but it reflects in the quality of their food. I think for new businesses to thrive in a small town like this it's important to show a little grace and patience as the kinks are worked out during the launch phase. Oh PS: The labeling on their drinks is adorable, but I am a sucker for cute things!

Lindsey Mueggenberg

25/11/2025

I love the food here, especially the chicken mozzarella sandwich. Crispy and delicious. Adan was at the window and was so friendly and made me feel welcomed.

Evelyn Salgado

11/11/2025

What a great concepto! My dod and I loved their welcoming environment and phenomenal quality of their food. Their Beef Dip Sandwich & Matcha tea, and not to mention their pup-cup, we're absolutely delicious. I hope they remain consistent, something this town lacks. #EvieApproves

Drate1 Farrow

21/09/2025

Me and my husband went here on a whim and were very pleased with our experience. We ordered our food last, so it was taking a moment to prepare (our fault anyways) and the owner offered an affogato to us for free while we waited. The food was delicious, fresh and warm upon receipt and the coffee was lovely. The ice cream is very creamy and paired nicely with their espresso. The affogato syrup was very rich and decadent. After some research, I learned that they use a lot more organic and fresh ingredients, which explained the increase in prep time. Overall the staff were polite, pleasant to talk with, and we had an awesome breakfast.

William Turner

16/09/2025

I visited during Grand Opening and the place was packed! Even though they were super busy the Owners took the time to great every customer they could! Then I ordered a delicious Ham panini sandwich, it was hot with gooey cheese and toasted bread. Then I got stone cold like cookies and cream ice cream, the best I’ve ever had! Since that day I’ve been back 3 times trying different flavors of ice cream and sandwiches. It’s been delicious every time! I’ll be back again soon! Service and food have been great every time!

Selisha Hernandez

10/09/2025

OMG! I cannot believe this place don’t have 5Stars!!!! I went today ( national pup day) my FIRST time there Adian was my order taker SO KIND AND HELPFUL, I let him know it was my first time there and asked what he would recommend, he asked if I was looking for food or a drink I specified a drink he said “ our lemonades are a huge hit right now what is your favorite flavor? We also have boba add ins” YALL I got a mango lemonade with MANGO BOBA my dogs EACH got a pup cup ( I have three dogs!) and Adian was sure to give each of them attention and was so respectful! I will be back 1000000 times over again! I can’t wait to try their salads!

Taja Ase

26/08/2025

I was up here for a work trip. This was my favorite spot to eat. The Roast Beef dip is good when you dip it in chipotle ranch. The strawberry lemonade is delicious. The staff were always helpful and happy.